Why Political Escalation is BAD | TaraElla News



Welcome to the new TaraElla News, where we examine the latest political and cultural news from the perspective of upholding classical liberal values like individual freedom, equal opportunity and free speech. We'll be doing this on most days of the week, subscribe if you're interested.

Today, I want to respond to a recent interview of Michael Malice by political commentator Lauren Chen. There are a few points where I strongly disagreed with Malice, and I think Chen also didn't explore in enough depth. In that interview, Malice described something he calls the 'New Right', which is more united by their shared opposition to what is sometimes called the New Left than by any common shared belief. I mean, what he describes is effectively diverse groups of people who have in common an opposition to postmodernism, identity politics and Critical Theory thinking. I think it's sufficient to state this plainly, and using a new label like the 'New Right' ironically risks encouraging identity politics. Besides, many people who are opposed to postmodernism, identity politics and Critical Theory don't necessarily identify as any type of 'Right'. I personally refuse to identify as either left or right, for example. I believe that thinking in terms of left vs right unnecessarily limts our horizons either way, and I rather like Andrew Yang's idea of 'not left, not right, but forward'. It should also be noted that, when this 'New Right' idea was raised by an article in Quilette earlier this year, many people responded that they wouldn't want to be a part of some 'New Right', because while they oppose identity politics and postmodernist thinking, they are lifelong Democrats, and they believe in Democratic policies on most issues from health care to climate change. In effect, the adoption of a label like the 'New Right' needlessly divides the coalition that opposes identity politics and postmodern critical theory, and is a most unwise move.

Malice went on to say that, one of the most important differences between the 'New Right' and the 'Old Right' is that the 'New Right' is much more skeptical and unforgiving of mainstream establishment media. However, this phenomenon is not just confined to the right. Rather, younger generations across the political spectrum have become very skeptical of the establishment media and its agenda. This awareness is strong on the right, the left, and even the moderate center. There are very few pro-establishment young people either way.

Another criticism I have of Malice is that he seems to think that political polarization and escalation may be a good thing because this way the center 'can't hold' anymore. This echoes an increasing feeling on both the left and the right that perhaps it might be a good thing for the status quo to give way to chaos, and for all out political war to break out, because they would be the winners in the end. However, this fantasy portrays a lack of understanding of history. Imperfect as it is, even the current status quo represents the accumulation of thousands of years of trial and error in human history, and an abrupt break with the past without careful consideration and consensus would almost certainly bring more losses than gains. Furthermore, history teaches us that periods of chaos are most often followed by long periods of authoritarian rule, and it may take a very long time just to get back to where we are today.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website, and my Medium profile. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

It's About LOVE: Why Marianne Williamson is Rising Quickly | TaraElla News



Welcome to the new TaraElla News, where we examine the latest political and cultural news from the perspective of upholding classical liberal values like individual freedom, equal opportunity and free speech. We'll be doing this on most days of the week, subscribe if you're interested.

Today, I want to look at the recent interest in 2020 Presidential candidate Marianne Williamson. At the beginning of this year, she received relatively little attention, and many counted her out of the race. But just these few weeks, she has been receiving a lot of attention. It probably started with the debates last month, when many people first learned about her. She has also had a few more media appearances, including, most recently, on the Rubin Report, where people from all over the political spectrum thought she did unexpectedly well.

So what's so special about Marianne Williamson? If you look at her policies, most of them are also offered by at least a few other candidates. They mostly look like what is now mainstream Democratic Party stuff. I mean, I love that she has promised not to bail out the big banks, but it's something several other candidates are also offering. Instead, her main message is love. Yes, it's all about the love. So does this mean she is for feelings above policies and fact?

Judging by her recent media appearances, Williamson is actually one smart woman, and she's pretty no-nonsense when she has to be. For example, when Dave Rubin claimed that the Democratic Party was veering towards open borders, Williamson quickly pointed out that this simply isn't true, that none of the 24 or so candidates actually support open borders. During that interview, Williamson also talked about the people who are surviving on low paid work and can't pay the bills, and the need to put corporate power in check, and she made a good case for her viewpoints. Many people have noted that Williamson was able to essentially correct many of the biases Rubin brought to the discussion. I mean, I think this is the problem with Rubin. I think his experiences with the 'Woke' cultural left being anti-free speech has colored his entire perception of the Democrats, and somehow he got the cultural issues and the economic issues mixed up. But then, Williamson used facts and logic to make a good case for her economic policies, and that's what's made her the winner in this encounter.

So Williamson is someone who cares about both facts and feelings. Is that OK? I think so. I mean, ever since Ben Shapiro popularized the slogan 'facts don't care about your feelings', many people have been thinking that the so-called left has been losing because it has been overtaken by a concern for feelings. But then, this oversimplifies the problem. Instead, as I have always argued, the 'Woke' cultural left's problem is their embrace of Critical Theory thinking, and in particular aspects of postmodern Critical Theory. The lack of concern for facts only applies to the postmodernist faction of the far-left, which the majority of Democrats, including Marianne Williamson, clearly don't subscribe to. For example, she has been keen to point out that the majority of Americans are not racist. For Williamson, it doesn't matter that some people feel like every Trump supporter is racist, because facts are facts, and the fact is that this is not true. Furthermore, the cultural left's problem with feelings is not that they care about feelings, but rather that they only care about the feelings of so-called oppressed groups, while being often quite cruel towards those they consider privileged. This comes from their Critical Theory worldview, which is where the whole Oppression Olympics thing originated. But if you look at Williamson, her love is for everyone. She doesn't divide people into the oppressors and the oppressed. She cares about the feelings of everyone, including those who struggle to pay their bills, a group that isn't generally considered oppressed in the Oppression Olympics worldview. I mean, there's still one big identity-based policy where I don't agree with Williamson, but overall I am satisfied that her brand of love is for everyone, and is not just for select groups.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website, and my Medium profile. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

The Lion King is Patriarchal? Critical Theory, Here We Go Again... | BreadBusting #13



Welcome to BreadBusting, where we attempt to examine the problematic ideas that come out of BreadTube, and the ideology of Breadism more generally. Basically, it's like Myth Busting, but for Breadism. We also talk about BreadTube adjacent phenomenon, that is, things that fans of BreadTube also happen to like or support, or have a strong opinion on.

The release of the remake of Disney's Lion King, coming 25 years after the original release, was greeted with excitement in many places. This is especially true of people around my age, many for whom back in 1994 The Lion King was one of their first movies. But just like everything in 2019, the culture wars are threatening to devour and ruin this classic too. In the wake of the remake, some feminists have raised concerns about The Lion King being supposedly patriarchal. Now, I can hear the trouble brewing, and screams of 'not again' from everyone. Most of us probably don't want another round of the good old SJW vs anti-SJW stuff that most people are probably tired of hearing about by now. Especially not to ruin a childhood classic.

But is The Lion King patriarchal? Let's examine some of those claims. The first claim is that lions are matrilineal, thus a realistic story about lions should feature a matrilineal society. Since The Lion King doesn't do this, it must be assuming patriarchal values. The second claim is that The Lion King features very few prominent female characters, especially by contemporary standards. But then, I think you need to understand that The Lion King is based on Shakespeare's Hamlet, which means that it's not meant to accurately reflect lions in nature, and it's not going to reflect 21st century pop culture feminism's standards either. As many have argued, forcing it to do either of these things would probably destroy the plot. Thinking about it from another angle, if The Lion King is problematic, then Shakespeare is problematic, and that is a stance that would go against many generations of literary consensus. Besides, there were no 'Lion King is patriarchal' complains back in 1994. Therefore, the idea that The Lion King is patriarchal and problematic reflects some very recent change in the perspective of some sections of society, and it's a fundamental change that goes against both the social consensus of many generations past, and even the social consensus of a time as recent as the 1990s.

I guess this shows that, the worries of many people that contemporary wokeness is out to destroy some aspects of our long-standing shared culture, can be seen as a valid concern, at least to some degree. As I often say, I totally support human rights and social justice as it is traditionally defined, but I have several major problems with the 'woke' ideology. One of those problems is the Critical Theory worldview, a worldview that informs a lot of the so-called 'woke' discourse, and also many of the common BreadTube perspectives. For those who are unfamiliar with such jargonistic terms, Critical Theory is an approach to examine society based on the belief that change is needed to liberate people from oppression, and that philosophical theory should not just examine society but should provide the needed change. Sounds noble, right? It's not so simple, though.

The problem is, if we always look at things from this viewpoint, we end up assuming that things are oppressive way too often. Instead of only seeing oppression when people actually complain there is oppression, those who see things through Critical Theory glasses see the potential for oppression in almost every situation. There are several pitfalls with this approach. Firstly, this creates a strong tendency to justify the dismantling and destruction of whatever culture we have. This is further compounded by the fact that Critical Theory culture often incorporates elements of Antonio Gramsci's theory of Cultural Hegemony, which further paints existant culture in an inherently bad light. We end up with an attitude that everything is bad, everything is problematic. We end up in a state of effective cultural nihilism, which is not healthy for either individuals or society as a whole. Secondly, the focus on critiquing existing things channels our energy into being against what is there, rather than looking to create what is not yet there. We need to remember that, most human rights advances in history have come during times of positive imagination, not times of negative introspection. For example, if feminists feel that The Lion King doesn't reflect their narrative or their ideals, they are welcome to create something like The Leopard Queen for example. To heavily focus on critique is to waste energy that could be channeled into more creative and constructive activities. Finally, the collective anxiety generated from destroying the things that people used to value, the things that used to connect us as a community, leads to increased conflict and weakens the social fabric. This eventually brings political instability, which risks descending into complete chaos. Students of early 20th century political history would know how dangerous that can be.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

Why Andrew Yang is ABSOLUTELY RIGHT on Free Marriage Counselling | #YangGang | TaraElla News

NOTE: While I did support certain candidates in the 2019–20 Democratic primaries because of their ideas (e.g. UBI, anti-war, broad tent approach), it doesn't mean I endorse their other positions.



Welcome to the new TaraElla News, where we examine the latest political and cultural news from the perspective of upholding classical liberal values like individual freedom, equal opportunity and free speech. We'll be doing this on most days of the week, subscribe if you're interested.

Today, I want to talk about the recent exchange between Andrew Yang and Meghan McCain on Yang's policy of providing free marriage counselling for all couples who want it. While Yang is most well-known for the Freedom Dividend, his platform is actually full of interesting and unique policies, you should go check it out if you haven't already. Yang justifies his policy of free marriage counselling on the fact that studies have proven children who grow up in two-parent households have a range of better outcomes. In other words, since it is better for the kids and hence better for society that mom and dad stay together, it is justified to spend money to help moms and dads everywhere stay together. Very logical.

In fact, I would add that there are other equally important reasons for providing free marriage counselling, that perhaps couldn't be proven by academic studies. For example, strong and stable families mean a stronger social fabric and a higher level of social trust, which would also mean that we can have more conducive discussions on social issues, and hence a more functional free market of ideas. There's also a case to be made that a strong social fabric and strong social institutions are needed to satisfy people's need for meaningful relationships and attachment, and if we improved on that front we are likely to see less tribalism and identity politics. Overall, there are indeed many reasons to support free marriage counselling, and I am actually surprised that not more candidates are having this in their platform.

So what problems did Meghan McCain have with Yang's policy of free marriage counselling? She seems to think that it's a one size fits all thing, and it wouldn't benefit people like herself, because her version of marriage counselling is more like drinking Jack Daniels, shooting some guns and hanging out. She goes on to say that, the universal peg for every hole approach is her problem with the 'left' right now. But then, as I understand it, it's not like couples must go to a particular state sponsored service to qualify for the benefit. As I understand it, couples who go to any licenced marriage counsellor can qualify for the benefit, and since different therapists have very different approaches, there is a large element of choice here, and it certainly isn't one size fits all. Of course, it won't cover couples who only want to drink some beer and shoot some guns. But then, we need to remember that the program is targeted at couples who are most at risk of marriage breakdown, and thus would benefit from some form of professional therapy. In other words, it's not meant for all couples, it's meant for those who need it. And even for couples who don't need it, they will still benefit from the general norm of stronger families and a stronger social fabric, so they will still get something out from it.

The other thing is, we should also probably remind Meghan McCain that Andrew Yang isn't necessarily in the 'left'. Anyone familiar with him would know the slogan 'not left, not right, but forward'. Besides, even the left, just like the right, is a diverse bunch, and I really hate seeing people who generalize and stereotype those on the opposite side of politics. Not everyone on the left believes in one size fits all policies, just like not everyone on the right is against gay marriage, for example.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website, and my Medium profile. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

Trump Feud With AOC, Omar Reveals Sad Truth About 2019 Tribal Politics | TaraElla News



Welcome to the new TaraElla News, where we examine the latest political and cultural news from the perspective of upholding classical liberal values like individual freedom, equal opportunity and free speech. We'll be doing this on most days of the week, subscribe if you're interested.

The news headlines in the past few days have been dominated by the feud between President Trump and a 'squad' of four left-wing Democrats, AOC, Ilhan Omar, Rashida Tlaib, and Ayanna Pressley. As a classical liberal and a free speech absolutist, my perspective is simple. Even though I have had plenty of disagreements with what AOC and Ilhan Omar have said in the past, they have every right to say what they believe, and it is clearly wrong to tell an American citizen to pack her bags and leave America just because she said something you didn't like. This would be morally no different to the de-platforming that happens in college campuses. Note that I don't stand with the 'squad' and what they have said at all, but I stand with the principle of free speech at all times, as any liberty loving individual would.

Looking at the controversy from another angle, many people have also asked the question of, why would President Trump give four very junior congresswomen so much attention? And I think here lies the more important lesson. In fact, many right-wing commentators have already given the game away. They are overjoyed that this episode has given the 'squad' so much prominence, imagining that perhaps they are now the public face of the Democratic Party going into the 2020 elections. In other words, they are happy to play up this identity-based culture war thing so that Trump and the Republicans can do better in November 2020. This shows that, as I have always argued, while identity-based culture wars have generally been launched by the Critical Theory wing of left, many actors on the right are also not below pouring gas on the fire if they think it would benefit their team.

In the past few years, with the rise of Critical Theory inspired identity politics in some sections of the left, some people have sought refuge from identitarianism by moving to the right. But ultimately, this is not an entirely satisfying solution either, to put it mildly. I mean, independent freedom fighters like myself are always committed to opposing the identity culture wars, whatever the consequences. To people like us, this chaos distracts from the important policy debates, and more importantly, fractures the social fabric and tears up the social contract with disasterous long-term consequences. Therefore, we believe that whatever your political affiliations are, it's simply never justified to encourage this chaos. On the other hand, commentators on networks like Fox News love to say that they are in the same fight as ourselves, especially when they denounce the latest outrage in college campus politics. But are they really in the same fight as us? I think their rather positive takes on the events of the past few days, and their strong focus on the potential boost for Trump going into 2020, speaks volumes on what their real priorities are.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website, and my Medium profile. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

Wokeness is Not Social Justice. It’s Establishment Elitism. | BreadBusting #12

Note: This article is a commentary on ‘wokeness’, as in the critical theory and postmodernism inspired worldview. Wokeness aside, I am still committed to being against racism, sexism, homophobia, transphobia, and bigotry in all forms. However, I believe our approach should be guided by liberal values.




Welcome to BreadBusting, where we attempt to examine the problematic ideas that come out of BreadTube, and the ideology of Breadism more generally. Basically, it's like Myth Busting, but for Breadism. We also talk about BreadTube adjacent phenomenon, that is, things that fans of BreadTube also happen to like or support, or have a strong opinion on.

Today, I want to discuss the recent controversy surrounding an interview on the website Spiked, featuring Chapo Trap House host Amber Frost and Red Scare host Anna Kachiyan, two anti-woke lefists according to the article published on Spiked. Frost, as you might know, is famous for coining the term 'dirtbag left', and Chapo is basically the home of dirtbag leftism. I have always found dirtbag leftism interesting and sort of respectable. I mean, they probably won't return my respect. Still, despite our differences, I can tell that the dirtbag left is the real deal when it comes to being anti-establishment, hence they know the value of being anti-woke. More on that later.

But first, what did Frost and Kachiyan do wrong to trigger the anger of the Woke Left? Nothing, in fact, besides being anti-woke.

So why is being anti-woke so cool? Because it's anti-establishment. I don't know why the Woke Left can't see it, but wokeness is literally a 1% establishment elite agenda, promoted by people from academics in humanity departments, to corporate CEOs, to Hollywood celebrities. To be anti-woke is to choose to side with the ideals of the silent majority, the good sense of everyday individuals, against the dogma of the elites. It is one thing to be pro-human rights, and I'm certainly pro-human rights, but being woke is actually just following dogma enforced by the elites. For me, and for many other people, the fact that the majority of people out there are not woke is good enough reason to be anti-woke. Being woke is to play into the elites' agenda, and is by definition pro-establishment, if you think about it. I guess you can't be truly anti-establishment without also being anti-woke.

The interview also included other, interesting, anti-woke criticisms of the modern so-called left. There was a good point about how race shouldn't matter, something the modern left seems to have forgotten. I have often said that only a colorblind society is true liberation, and only a colorblind society can have true solidarity, and it seems that at least some leftists still agree with this traditional progressive wisdom. Another point I liked was their support for free speech. As a free speech absolutist, I have become disappointed at the erosion of free speech on the left in recent years. People like Frost and Kachiyan give me real hope that the spirit of the 1960s Free Speech Movement is still not entirely dead on the left. Yet.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website, and my Medium profile. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

Who is Jackie Jackson Anyway? | Re ContraPoints | BreadBusting #10



Welcome to BreadBusting, where we attempt to examine the problematic ideas that come out of BreadTube, and the ideology of Breadism more generally. Basically, it's like Myth Busting, but for Breadism. Please note that, while I do have my personal political beliefs, all this is done in the name of intellectual discussion and seeing things from different perspectives. This is the third and final part of my response to the latest ContraPoints video, titled Transtrenders. Today, we will focus on Jackie Jackson, host of The Freedom Report.

Is Jackie meant to be a classical liberal? Probably. Her show is called The Freedom Report, she talks about freedom and free speech all the time, and earlier on she gave me some Dave Rubin vibes. But then, maybe she is meant to be a centrist instead, because she jokingly said she would take the 'centrist' position in this latest video. Finally, another possibility is that she has become a hardline conservative as of late, because in this most recent video she clearly sounded more like Milo Yiannopoulos than Dave Rubin! While there have been concerns throughout the political spectrum surrounding some of the topics Jackie raised, her attitude is clearly much more to the right of your average classical liberal or centrist. In short, Jackie Jackson appears to have a political identity crisis, and she doesn't even know what she believes!

In fact, Jackie Jackson is PURE IMAGINATION!


I actually think that Jackie Jackson is a characature of what a leftist would imagine a non-leftist to be. She's not specifically a centrist, a classical liberal, a libertarian or a conservative, but a confused and unrealistic mix of all these things! She's Dave Rubin, Ben Shapiro, Joe Rogan, Tucker Carlson, Sarah Palin, Donald Trump, Ron Paul, Steven Crowder, Jordan Peterson and more, but all rolled into one person! I still remember Natalie accusing Jordan Peterson of blurring the differences between the different groups on the left, well, Jackie Jackson is the exact same thing, except for doing it to people outside the left. In the real world, Jackie Jackson simply can't exist. To give an analogy a leftist would understand, it would be as if somebody was a fan of President Obama but was also a committed anarcho-communist. In the real world, Jackie's confused politics would mean that she would have no followers at all. Jackie is simply the left-wing's jumbled up collective imagination of what their enemy looks like.

I guess Jackie Jackson is most symbolic of one thing: the left's tendency to imagine straw-man enemies who don't actually exist. Don't get me wrong, the right does this too, for example with their whole 'Comrade Obama' thing, but Jackie is clearly a product of the imagination of the left. In fact, as a non-leftist who is also a regular reader of many left-wing websites and publications, I have found that many leftist writers do this regularly. It often sounds like they don't get why centrist or right-leaning people hold a particular view, but rather imagine that they hold that view because they have an agenda of deliberately oppressing people. In fact, what many centrist and right-leaning people fear most is social engineering, changing society based on ivory tower generated theories, which they fear will bring real world disasterous consequences. Leftists never seem to address this concern.

Conservatives, centrists and classical liberals are also fundamentally different in many ways. In particular, they have different attitudes to proposed civil rights reforms. Conservatives often justify their blanket opposition to proposed civil rights reforms based on fears about some kind of social engineering agenda. On the other hand, centrists and liberals generally hear all sides of the debate, and make their case for a cautious version of the reform by pointing out that it wouldn't lead to enabling the social engineering agenda. The gay marriage debate had plenty of this dynamic, for example. The pro-gay marriage side won by simply convincing most people there's no sinister social engineering plot behind it. As a result of that debate, people like Dave Rubin are happily enjoying their newly won civil right, while people like Ben Shapiro grudgingly admit that the sky hasn't fallen in after all. Leftist commentary seems to ignore all this, and imagine all non-leftists to be a uniform bloc of reactionary people who literally want to oppress other people. This can't be further from the truth!

In these supposedly polarizing times, there has been calls for people from all sides to get together and have constructive discussions. But this can only happen if people stop stereotyping their opponents.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

The Self-Help to Right-Wing Pipeline? | BreadBusting #7



Welcome to BreadBusting, where we attempt to examine the problematic ideas that come out of BreadTube, and the ideology of Breadism more generally. Basically, it's like Myth Busting, but for Breadism. Please note that, while I do have my personal political beliefs, all this is done in the name of intellectual discussion and seeing things from different perspectives. Today, I want to respond to a point that Caleb Cain, i.e. Faraday Speaks, sort of touched on during a recent interview with David Pakman. As I understood it, Caleb said that part of the reason why he went over to the hard right was because he got into the self-help philosophy of Stefan Molyneux, who also linked his life philosophy to cultural traditionalism, and from there to right-wing politics. This point was made in the context of discussing Caleb's journey into the political right. Moving on from this, David and Caleb also extended their discussion to Jordan Peterson, who David seems to think has a similar issue.

I guess if people are selling their politics via self-help, then it's a real issue, and we need to call it out. But as to whether Jordan Peterson or even Stefan Molyneux are doing that, I think it's very debatable. While it is true that they do link their self-help philosophy to encouragement of traditional lifestyles, I don't think this is necessarily unrelated or deceptive. Let's start from this example. Say I wrote a self-help book, and it advised readers to stay away from drugs and alcohol. You could say that is encouraging a traditional lifestyle. But if I told my readers to stay away from drugs and alcohol, it would be because I want them to lead healthy lives, for their own good, rather than because I have any political agenda. But then, there are many other lifestyle decisions that could lead to healthier and happier lives, and many of those also happen to involve living a relatively traditional lifestyle. At least I can personally understand and agree with this point. For example, I would think that advising readers against casual sex is also a good thing to write in a self-help book.

Now, all this would be politically neutral, at least in the pre-1960s era. Even before the 1960s, we had lots of very left-wing people, but they generally wouldn't take issue with traditional lifestyle advice. All this changed after the 1960s and 70s, a time where many problematic developments occured. Firstly, there was the proliferation of critical theory on the left, something that I think was a mixed bag with some problematic results to be honest. Furthermore, the kind of critical theory that took hold at this time had a strong critique of family values in general and the nuclear family in particular, linking it to capitalism. Now, this line of reasoning goes all the way back to Engels in the 19th century, but personally I have never found it convincing. If anything, capitalism has never been pro-family: we used to have strong extended families in feudal times, but early capitalism broke them up into nuclear families for the sake of labor flexibility, and later capitalism further eroded the family unit. I also happen to believe that we need to culturally limit this tendency of capitalism, because otherwise liberalism will effectively self-destruct, and fascism will grow. But that's another story. The point is, leftist critical theory began to look negatively on values associated with strong families since the 1960s and 70s, and because of that the left has been against many traditional lifestyle values for no good moral or economic reason since then. For example, the aforementioned advice against casual sex would be frowned upon, as a pro-patriarchy message, or even a carrier of cultural hegemony.

As someone who sees things primarily through classical liberal values, when I look at something, I want to see there being liberty and equal opportunity. I guess you could say that this was the majority viewpoint of progressives before 1960, and back then both capitalist liberals and socialist lefists would agree on many things culturally despite disagreeing economically. Where both liberty and equal opportunity have been satisfied, then I'm satisfied. From a classical liberal viewpoint, that is, the default of the pre-1960s progressives, life advice that tends to traditional choices, for example abstinence outside of marriage, would be value-neutral, and it should be treated fairly like all other ideas in the free market of ideas, as long as there isn't an implication of endorsing state coercion. So where, in the past, the left stayed true to these values, people who lived and promoted traditional lifestyles could live happily on either side of the political spectrum. But since the 1970s, this was no longer true. I think this is why many people who start out from believing in traditional lifestyles for their own good also end up finding the right side of the political spectrum a more hospitable place for them. And I think this is where the left has given itself a massive own goal.

Therefore, my advice is this: if the left is so worried about people like Jordan Peterson and Stefan Molyneux using their self-help to move people into right-wing politics, then they should make a real effort to cease alienating people who believe in traditional lifestyle choices. My point is, the ball is in the Left's court, and they alone will decide if this so-called pipeline continues to exist. As soon as they drop that anti-traditional side of critical theory, and go back to their pre-1960s cultural views, this so-called pipeline will cease to exist.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

A Classical Liberal Case for Pete Buttigieg? | Moral Libertarian View

NOTE: While I did support certain candidates in the 2019–20 Democratic primaries because of their ideas (e.g. UBI, anti-war, broad tent approach), it doesn't mean I endorse their other positions.



Welcome to Moral Libertarian View, a podcast style program where we discuss big ideas to see if they can contribute to more individual liberty and equal opportunity, values that are at the heart of the Moral Libertarian idea. Unlike many popular channels out there, this show is a dedicated non echo-chamber, where views from the left, right and center are all going to be considered without discrimination. I hope you subscribe if you are interested.

In the recent debate for 2020 Democratic candidates, Pete Buttigieg was one of the most noticed personalities. At only 37 years old, he is the youngest candidate in the field, but many people have found him surprisingly mature in his thinking. Here at Moral Libertarian View, we have a habit of analysing people and platforms from a classical liberal values point of view, to see if they are good for freedom or not. With the renewed interest in Mayor Pete, I think it's time we look at him throughly from the freedom viewpoint.

If you visit the Pete Buttigieg 2020 website, you will see that he has divided his whole platform into three categories, with Freedom being one of them. So, at least from the surface, we see a man who says he is committed to freedom, which is already much better than many people these days. Pete says that his emphasis is on both 'freedom of' and 'freedom from', and I guess this means both things like 'freedom of speech' and 'freedom from a lack of health care'. Consequently, his website details many policies to do with social programs, like health care and education. As I frequently say, as a Moral Libertarian, my main emphasis is that everyone should have equal and maximum moral agency, and I believe this is the moral core of the classical liberal values as espoused by its 18th and 19th century proponents. This means that, while I generally agree with political libertarians on many social issues, when it comes to economic issues I think having a strong social safety net is valuable from an individual freedom point of view. I previously made my Moral Libertarian case as to why expanding health care and education programs is worth the money, so I am in general agreement with Mayor Pete here.

While Mayor Pete is for spending more on health and education, his plans have been criticized by those further to the left. For example, his 'Medicare for All Who Want It' is seen as a cop-out among those who believe in achieving 'Medicare For All' overnight. Similarly, while he clearly states that he wants public college to be free for middle income families, this is still not free college for all. However, I think that the important thing is to have a policy that does what it wants to do, and the objective here is to have health insurance coverage for all, and make the cost of college no longer a problem for all who want to attend. From what I see, Pete's policies achieve these objectives. His plan for Medicare also appears to preserve an element of choice, which is good from a classical liberal perspective. I don't actually understand why the left seems to have a problem with Mayor Pete's policies here. I mean, if you can convince me otherwise, then I will listen, but personally I don't see a problem there. Furthermore, Pete's platform also states that he wants to put an end to the endless wars, which is encouraging to hear, even if he has not put much emphasis on this policy yet.

Overall, from what I can see, Mayor Pete is committed to freedom generally, and his social programs sound reasonable. I still have some concern about where he stands on critical theory, which comes from both his background and some of the statements he has made, but I am relieved that at least his policies don't reflect this mindset. Otherwise, there don't seem to be any red flags I can see in his platform either.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website, and my Medium profile. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

Can Someone Like Bernie Sanders AND Joe Biden at the same time? | TaraElla Report Radio



Welcome to TaraElla Report Radio, a podcast style program where we discuss big ideas to see if they can contribute to more individual liberty and equal opportunity. Unlike many popular channels out there, this show is a dedicated non echo-chamber, where we look at things from a truly independent perspective. I hope you subscribe if you are interested.

Tonight, the second round of the first debate for the 2020 Democratic candidates will take place, and it is the round most people are excited about, because there will be many big names like Andrew Yang, Kamala Harris, Pete Buttigieg, Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden. Speaking of Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden, they are not the only two oldest and most experienced candidates in the race, they are also probably the most polarizing ones. It sometimes seems like if you love Bernie you must hate Uncle Joe, or vice versa. But then, there are plenty of people who have indicated to pollsters that they either have Bernie as their first choice and Biden as their second, or vice versa. Today, I'm going to ask this question: can somebody actually like Sanders and Biden at the same time. I guess I'm in a good position to look at this, because neither of them are my favorite, but both are in my Top 5. Furthermore, I also once looked at if someone can like Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump at the same time, so this looks like a fitting follow-up.

So why would someone like Bernie and Biden at the same time? Most of the people who have this preference seem to not be active in the internet political scene, so we can't know what they think for sure. At least Sanders-Trump fans are more outspoken. But Sanders-Biden fans tend to not be similarly outspoken for some reason. Some people have hypothesized that people holding this preference could just be due to name recognition. But then, plenty of big names have already received lots of media coverage, so if it was true back in January, it can't still be true now. Others have suggested these people would only support men, possibly due to sexism. Again, I don't think this is right. I have never met a single person in my whole life who would only vote for men as a rule. Besides, there are plenty of other men in the running, and we don't see nearly as many people going Biden-Buttigieg or Sanders-O'Rourke, for example. But Biden-Sanders, or Sanders-Biden, seem to be quite common.

I guess there are plenty of things that Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden actually share, that are not as important to many activists, but could be quite important to your average voter. From the top of my head, I can think of experience, perceived reliability, and a lack of identity politics as three big things they share. Firstly, most voters value experience, and both Sanders and Biden have lots of it. In fact, if either were elected President in 2020, they would be the oldest newly elected president in US history. Secondly, experience also links with perceived reliability. The longer one can maintain a track record without serious stuff-ups, the better the perceived reliability. Finally, an under-appreciated factor is the widespread loathing of identity politics throughout America and most Western countries. I know this is an unpopular opinion, but I firmly believe that Hillary lost in 2016 because of identity politics. I mean, it was stupid for Hillary to go with identity politics, there was already the example of a certain leader of another English speaking country who tried a similar thing a few years earlier with disasterous results, so I don't know why Hillary would choose to go there. But even in the 2020 race, we still see several big name contenders who like to play up their identity politics, as if they want to become the new Hillary. Against this background, Bernie and Biden both look like the way to escape a repeat of Hillary 2016. I should add that, if escaping from identity politics is important to you, you should probably also check out Andrew Yang and Tulsi Gabbard, both excellent candidates who never play identity politics.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website, and my Medium profile. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

Jordan Peterson says Speak The Truth. But it may Require a Revolution | Moral Libertarian View



Welcome to Moral Libertarian View, a podcast style program where we discuss big ideas to see if they can contribute to more individual liberty and equal opportunity, values that are at the heart of the Moral Libertarian idea. Unlike many popular channels out there, this show is a dedicated non echo-chamber, where views from the left, right and center are all going to be considered without discrimination. I hope you subscribe if you are interested.

Today, I want to respond to a clip Jordan Peterson recently uploaded, where he encouraged people to speak the truth. His message was that, we should all conceptualize the highest good that we can, aim at that, and then tell the truth. Basically, we should speak as per our conscience believes. If we all do that, we will have a much better world. A very simple message, and one I totally agree with. The reason why I'm a Moral Libertarian is because I believe people can't be always right, and all ideas from all individuals need to be challenged in the free market of ideas regularly, so we can get closer to the truth. To participate in the free market of ideas in good conscience would of course require us to speak the whole truth of what we believe. There's one problem though: we live in a world where it's often not easy to speak the truth.

Many people would say that the problem is a lack of free speech. For example, people are socially punished for saying controversial things, even losing their jobs for it, and there are also activists who de-platform speakers for a variety of reasons. My regular audience would know that I am deeply concerned about these things. But the problem actually goes much deeper. The problem is that, many people, no matter their background or belief, simply don't want to listen to ideas they don't agree with. Too many people like to live within their echo chamber, with their views never being challenged. If their views are ever challenged, they somehow feel unsafe, and they react very badly. This is the reason why we often can't have rational and constructive debates on important issues.

The fact is, even before so-called 'safe speech' became a thing, the safe speech mentality was already pervasive in many social circles. I know this because, being the outspoken person that I am, I have regularly received social backlash, even 10 or 12 years ago. The truth is, the safe speech mentality is not new, and if we are to be free to speak the truth, we must actively overcome it. To overcome the safe speech mentality, we need a revolution in the way we think about many things. For example, from now on, we need to agree 100% that it is never impolite to disagree. We should expect even our close friends to disagree with us all the time. Furthermore, we should actively step out of our echo chambers, and step out into the wider world, to listen to all the diverse voices out there. Many of us actually live in social circles that are akin to safe spaces, and that's not healthy. To counterbalance this, we need to actively expose ourselves to the full range of people and ideas out there. Finally, we need to remember not to take any disagreements personally. We need to remember that, to regularly have someone disagree with our point of view is a natural fact of life, not a statement of our deficiency. Besides, if we are truly confident about what we believe in, and we are certain that we have sound arguments for our belief, we wouldn't feel bad about others disagreeing. On the other hand, when we are not truly confident of our own position, which is certainly more frequent than people would admit, then we need to give the other side a fair go to change our minds.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. The transcripts are available on my website, and my Medium profile. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

Why BreadTube is Getting So Excited About a Joe Biden 'Gaffe' | BreadBusting



Welcome to BreadBusting, where we attempt to examine the problematic ideas that come out of BreadTube, and the ideology of Breadism more generally. Basically, it's like Myth Busting, but for Breadism. Today, I'm going to talk about why some BreadTubers, or at least BreadTube fans and BreadTube adjacent creators, have been getting very excited about some comments from former Vice President Joe Biden, which have been widely misinterpreted in the media.

Recently, Joe Biden described how he has a long track record of being able to work with people who he strongly disagreed with, including those who supported segregation back in the 1970s, because there was civility. As I understand it, the point is about being able to maintain a civil relationship with people who you have strong disagreements, so that you can still find common ground and get things done. A very important point to make, especially in this toxic political climate, where we can't even have reasonable debates anymore. Nonetheless, many people have been trying to make something out of nothing, accusing Joe Biden of being sympathetic to racists, when this was the exact opposite of what he actually said. Of course, attacking Biden over almost anything is quite easy these days, especially on the internet where he is pretty unpopular with activists from both the left and the right.

But then, if your average Bernie Sanders or Donald Trump supporter is perhaps promoting this controversy strategically, even if out of somewhat bad faith, Breadists are excited about this so-called gaffe for much deeper reasons. You see, Breadists don't believe in rational debate or civility. In the Breadist worldview, everything is about power, power struggle and power dynamics. Breadism sees everything through the lens of power, and believe that speech is only a device of power. While Joe Biden saw his ability to work with segregationists in the light of being civil despite fundamental disagreements, Breadism sees his ability to get along with racist people as part of his 'white privilege', operating in the power structure they call 'white supremacy'. Therefore, while Biden takes an opportunity to highlight his ability to work with those he disagreed with, Breadists saw an opportunity to highlight his white privilege, and his role in what they call 'white supremacy'. The problem with this attitude is that, if all we emphasize are our differences and our conflicts of interest, there is simply no way to work together towards anything. And this point was echoed even by progressives like Tulsi Gabbard.

In fact, historically, real progressives have long been uncomfortable with the Breadist view of breaking down everything into power and privilege analyses. 20th century French philosopher Michel Foucault was perhaps the most important influence on modern Breadism, and he saw everything from science and medicine to tradition and even knowledge itself as power structures. This essentially nihilistic view of the world was rejected by even Noam Chomsky himself! In fact, the rise of Breadist ideas is the fundamental reason why much of the left has become averse to rational debate, and instead promote authoritarian stances like safe speech and de-platforming speakers. For the committed Breadists, ideas and debate don't matter, because they are only a cloak for power and privilege. Unlike most Bernie or Trump supporters, Breadists oppose Joe Biden not because of policy differences, but because they fundamentally believe he stands for the powerful and the privileged, and his latest comments are proof of this. From a fundamentally Breadist point of view, it matters more that Joe Biden comes across like the embodiment of straight white male privilege, more than what anything Joe Biden actually has to say. And I think this is really sad.

That's all for today. I'll be back next time to discuss another big idea. Subscribe if you want to follow our story. And remember to resist the hive mind and stay individualistic. The world depends on it.

Why BreadTube is a Left-Wing Rabbit Hole | Re Caleb Cain (Faraday Speaks) | BreadBusting



Welcome to BreadBusting, where we attempt to examine the problematic ideas that come out of BreadTube, and the ideology of Breadism more generally. Basically, it's like Myth Busting, but for Breadism. Today, I'm going to talk about the political journey of Caleb Cain, aka Faraday Speaks, who used to be a far-right fellow-traveller for a while, but is now a left-winger. His story first came to prominence when he made a video about his journey a few months ago, and I have actually been following what he had to say since then. About two weeks ago, New York Times had an article about him, which caused even greater discussion.

Basically, as I understand it, Caleb started out as your average liberal young man, who got exposed to some right-wing ideas on YouTube. It all started when he became a fan of Stefan Molyneux. But then, the YouTube algorithm also introduced him to other right-wing channels, including both mainstream conservatives like Ben Shapiro and Steven Crowder, and other, much much further right channels. But it all changed when he got into creators like Destiny and ContraPoints, which pulled him back towards the left. But now, he's gone even further left than before, leftier than your average American liberal, although I don't know exactly where he stands on the issues. Towards the end of the NYT article, the journalist stated his concerns that Caleb, having just crawled out of a right-wing rabbit hole, may be falling into a left-wing rabbit hole. Caleb apparently doesn't share that concern very much.

The problem is, BreadTube is indeed a left-wing rabbit hole. Behind the fun and games, BreadTube creators are introducing people to very radical ideas. Ideas like how everything we know is socially constructed, how we don't actually have that much individual agency after all, and, in some cases, how everything we know and love, from families, to religion, to the liberal notion of individualism, is only here to serve capitalism. A good example is how, Breadism would have you believe that homophobia is due to the existence of the nuclear family, which in turn is due to the capitalist demand for workers. Honestly, this sounds like a conspiracy theory. And if you look at Breadist ideas, they ultimately all point to one theme. Everything you have come to know is evil, and is responsible for racism, sexism, homophobia, and every other social ill. Every traditional social institution stands in the way of your liberation. And social engineering to abruptly change everything is hence justified. Any resistence to this agenda is the exercise of oppressive power by the privileged, and if you don't see that, you must have false consciousness caused by cultural hegemony. I know that's a lot of jargon to take in, but that's Breadism, also known as Critical Theory and Postmodernism, in a nutshell.

The problem with BreadTube is, they've got some very controversial ideas, and they need to promote these ideas while not turning people away. Critical theory and postmodernism have been around for decades, but they had been widely rejected until recently. Some BreadTubers apparently believe that it is the serious attitude of thinkers like Adorno, or the academic jargon they use, that's unpalatable. That's why they dress their message up as entertainment. My concern is, if people take the messages of Breadism in this way, they may be less critical of what the message actually is. The problem is, we are generally less critical of entertainment than of serious lecturing. But if you think about it critically, it's not just the academic jargon in Breadism that's unpalatable. In fact, it's the ideology itself that's unpalatable. An ideology that calls for the dissolution of everything we know and love is inherently unpalatable. An ideology that encourages minorities to adopt a victim mentality is going to be rightly opposed by supporters of real social justice, as it used to be defined before 2010. BreadTube may have dressed Breadism up as entertaining and harmless, but if you scratch the surface, you will find some really problematic stuff.

That's all for today. I hope you subscribe if you are interested. See you next time!